← All bug reports

FS#1089Convert polyline from segments on locked layers deletes the segments

Type
Bug
Status
Closed
Resolution
Fixed
Category
QCAD/CAM
Severity
Low
Priority
Low
Reported version
3.6.3
Operating system
Windows 7
Reported
2014-08-21 by 0xdeadbeef
Closed
2015-07-27 by andrew
Votes
1

If you select (line) segments in a visible yet locked layer and choose "convert segments to polyline" (OG), the segments are deleted, but inserting the polyline fails.
So you can easily destroy locked layers by mistake which contradicts the idea of locking layers.

Comments (3)

0xdeadbeef 2014-08-22

I'm not sure how the severity can be low for such a fundamental issue.
If I lock a layer it must not be possible to easily destroy its continent by mistake.

andrew 2014-08-22

Severity is always subjective :)
'High' severity means usually crash when using a part of the software.
'Medium' means that a major part of the software cannot be used due to the bug.
Neither of that seems to be the case here - if the bug occurs you get a warning, hit undo and you're fine to continue.

0xdeadbeef 2014-08-22

If you notice the warning. Else you might notice minutes, hours or days later that you deleted an object from a layer that you considered locked - and no undo can bring it back.